1. Shortly after Mom finished grad school in Iowa City, my parents left the state. Dad had visited the Pacific Northwest when he was a teenage boyscout on a canoe trip. While high on evergreens and humidity-free air, he decided it was the best place on earth. Mom wanted to be where Dad was, so when he got a job in Kennewick, that was it: moving day. They didn't mind that Kennewick was a suburb of the Hanford Nuclear Site, or that it was in the desert. It was in Washington State. It wasn't Iowa. That was good enough.
2. No one ever sat me down and told me the true story of how two young, ambitious, left-brained Iowans ended up in Washington state with a poet for a daughter and a lawyer for a son. I couldn't tell you where I got my information or even if it's accurate because I'd rather not ask. I like my story. I like it so much that I wouldn't be surprised to find out I made it up.

3. When I was a child, we didn't go to Hawaii or Mexico or the Grand Canyon for summer vacation. We went to Omaha, Carroll, Makoqueta, Dubuque and Waterloo. In all the important ways, my summer vacations haven't really changed. My Aunt Gail lives outside Des Moines now, so now I go to Des Moines. I decided to come here instead of applying to a fancy writing conference this summer not because I'm not ambitious, but because when a super cool lady who lives in the American Gothic house offers to host you for a writing and baking residency and set you up with a pie-judging gig at the Iowa State Fair, you don't say no. You say yes, board a plane, and go meet your new friend Beth Howard. Besides. I can write in Iowa. I'm doing it right now.

4. The worst pie I had at the Machine Shed Pie Contest was a sour cream raisin pie that used fat free sour cream and 1/4 teaspoon ground cloves in the filling. Teresa from Kitchen Collage in Des Moines says that you can't understand the appeal of raisin cream pie until you try one made with unpasteurized full-fat sour cream. That's how it's supposed to be made: with the rich and piquant ingredients a farmer has on hand during winter. I awarded first place to a lightly-spiced full-fat specimen decorated with cookie cut-outs and crenellated whipped cream because I did not want to stop eating it. That's the number one sign of a great pie.

5. The best pie I tasted at the Iowa State Fair was a first prize rhubarb pie with a glorious crust and just a touch of orange peel in the filling. I can't remember the name of the baker, but I know people heard it a lot that afternoon. Four or five women took most of the top honors even though we judged blindly. "The old pros come with clipboards," my aunt said, "and mark off their wins and losses."
6. About a half hour before the show started, a guy named Dale sat down across the aisle and struck up a conversation. I was cold at first, the way I'm cold to people who want to talk to me on the bus. Then I felt foolish--he's not hitting on me, I realize. He's Iowan. He just wants to chat. I'd say the Iowan habit of chat is unnerving, but it's not--it's disarming. What's unnerving is my reticence. Where did I learn to be wary of nice strangers? How does my "Seattle freeze" help me get along in Seattle?

7. Dale took a couple days off from his construction company ("I've built over 700 decks," he said, and I wondered where all that wood came from) to get up at three in the morning and bake perfect lemon meringue and peach custard pies. Later that afternoon when he won second place for his gorgeous lemon meringue pie, Aunt Gail heard him dismiss the award. "I'm not interested in second place," he said, but he kept his wide smile. Every time one of the old pros bagged another blue ribbon, she smiled modestly and waved to the appreciative crowd as if she was surprised. Except for a pretty blond woman named Kathleen, who grinned and clapped like she just won a bunch of money. Which, come to think of it, she might have. Beth Howard warned me that people take this competition very seriously. I've started to see what she means.

8. As part of my judging duties I was supposed to whisper feedback into my writer's ear. My writer's name was Carol. We're both hard of hearing. "Don't mark them down too harshly," she advised as she showed me the ropes. "The good ones will rise to the top anyway and there's no reason to make everyone else feel bad. People try really hard here." This is going to be a little like a writing workshop, I realized, except that I have to put the art in my mouth.
9. As the judging wears on, my feedback begins to fit a pattern, much like it does when I give my writing students a feedback sandwich. Flavorful crust, but tough. Nice meringue! And, Excellent peach flavor, but the filling is a bit too gummy. More lemon juice next time? "Don't take too long with any of the pies," Carol says. "Just decide and go. You've got a lot to cover." Carol isn't joking. They ask me to do the peach pie category next. "It has twelve, is that okay?" says a nice lady with napkins. "Yep," I say. "Bring it on."

10. I want to talk about how one should not make peach pie. I don't mean in general. I mean in the way I saw it made at the Iowa State fair. First of all, peach pie should never be garnished by one long white hair that makes the front row of the audience gasp when I pull it out and hold it up in shock. But mostly, peach pie should not be made with almond extract. It makes the peaches taste canned. Teresa at Kitchen Collage says the difference between successful addition of flavoring to peach pie is the use of an almond emulsion instead of flavoring. "Extract sits at the front of your mouth like bad salsa, while an emulsion is a back-end flavor. It should linger on your palate, not overwhelm the peaches." I say to hell with it all and use just a little nutmeg, salt, and lemon so all we taste is perfect peachy peach. Why Iowan bakers overwhelmingly relied on almond extract to flavor their pies makes absolutely no sense to me--I mean, they're so proud of whether or not they use Colorado or Missouri peaches. Why would they mask them in flavoring? Is it possible that people like the taste of canned peaches out here? I just can't believe it. If someone out there has a clue, please give it to me.

Tomorrow I drive to Eldon, Iowa, home of Beth Howard's Pitchfork Pie Stand and a bunch of houses Grant Wood didn't get around to painting. To be continued...